A stranger reuses one

GoalpieceCC-BY-4.0practiced By Campaign Hub

The finish line for a single specimen: someone who does not know the author can reuse it, without asking a question the specimen should have answered.

When to use

Use this goal when you need to decide whether one specimen is finished. The finish line is a stranger's reuse, not a publish stamp.

When not to

Do not use this goal to declare a whole platform finished. Do not count a published empty page, or an author walking through their own work, as the stranger's reuse.

Author-attested

Original teaching specimen written for the Campaign Hub library. Not a transcript of a private run.

Community-submitted content. Prompts, skills, and agent instructions can contain hidden or malicious instructions (prompt injection). Review it before running it in any agent that has tool access, secrets, or the ability to spend money or send messages.
# A stranger reuses one This file is a goal: the outcome that tells you the work is finished. ## When to use Use this goal when you are tempted to call a specimen finished because it is published, because the file exists, or because the author is satisfied. The finish line is narrower and easier to observe. One specimen is finished when a person who does not know the author can reuse that specimen. ## When not to Do not apply this goal to a campaign, a platform, or a backlog. It judges one specimen. A shelf of unfinished specimens is not saved by one finished specimen, and one finished specimen is not unfinished because the shelf is larger than itself. Do not substitute the author's own dry run. The author already knows the missing step. The stranger does not. ## The specimen The artifact is this goal. ```text name: a stranger reuses one subject: one specimen finished_when: - A person who did not write the specimen can carry it out. - They do not ask the author a question the specimen should have answered. - They can point at the check the specimen names, and they can say what a broken copy does. not_finished_when: - Only the author can operate it. - The stranger has to invent a missing step, a missing input, or a missing stop. - The shelf has a submission form and no specimen to copy. - The specimen is published, and publication is the only evidence offered. evidence: - what the stranger changed - what the stranger left alone - whether the specimen's check went red on a broken copy they made on purpose author's role during the test: silent ``` The evidence is three notes from the stranger. A publish stamp is not on that list. The form of the specimen they reused is defined by the glossary entry "Specimen." This goal does not redefine that word. It says when one specimen has done its job. ## How a stranger checks it A stranger checks the goal by running it once, on one specimen, with the author silent. 1. Hand the specimen to someone who did not write it. Give them no side channel. 2. Ask them to reuse it for its stated situation. 3. Collect three notes: what they changed, what they left, and what the check did on a broken copy. 4. If they had to ask a question the specimen itself should have answered, the goal is not met. Write down the question. That question is the next edit to the specimen. The goal text itself fails if `finished_when` can be satisfied by the author alone, or by a status file, without the stranger.

How a stranger checks it

Related

goal reuse stranger finish

view raw view JSON