{"slug":"one-value-one-source","title":"One value, one source","description":"A practice that stayed in force because a check can see it: a fact has one home, a second copy names that home, and a reader can point at the home.","body":"# One value, one source\n\nThis file is a best practice: one home for a fact, with the check that a reader can point at that home.\n\n## When to use\n\nUse this practice when you notice the same fact in two places: a definition, a threshold, a roster row, a sentence on a page. Choose the home. Make every other appearance point at that home.\n\nThe practice earns its place because the check is something a stranger can do with a finger and the files. They can point at the home, or they cannot.\n\n## When not to\n\nDo not use this practice to justify a single giant file that holds unrelated facts. One home per fact, not one home for the whole library.\n\nDo not point at a home that readers of the public shelf cannot open. A private note is not a public fact's home. If the fact is public, the home is public.\n\n## The specimen\n\nThe artifact is this practice, with its check named.\n\n```text\npractice: one value, one source\n\nstatement:\n  A fact has one home.\n  A second copy names that home.\n  On disagreement, the home wins and the second copy is stale.\n\ncheck, named and runnable by a stranger:\n  1. Pick one fact.\n  2. Point at its home. One file, one field, or one specimen.\n  3. Find every other place the fact appears.\n  4. Each of those places names the home.\n  5. If a copy states a rival value and does not name the home, the check fails.\n  6. If two places both look like homes, the check fails until one of them points at the other.\n\nworked example on this shelf:\n  fact: the four stratum sentences\n  home: the kinds file\n  second copy: the glossary specimen \"The four strata\"\n  the glossary copy quotes the sentences and names the kinds file\n  if they ever disagree, the kinds file wins\n\n  fact: the shape of a specimen file\n  home: the schema campaignhub.specimen/v1\n  second copy: the glossary entry \"Specimen,\" which defines the word and names the schema\n  the glossary does not become a second schema\n\n  fact: the numeric line at which a safety answer blocks\n  home: the sensor question pack\n  the scorecard names that pack and does not keep a private copy of the number\n```\n\nThe check is the reason this is a practice and not a preference. A reader either can point at the home or they cannot. \"We were careful\" is not the observation.\n\n## How a stranger checks it\n\nRun the named check on the worked example. You need the kinds file and the glossary specimen \"The four strata.\"\n\n1. Read the four stratum sentences in the kinds file. That file is the home.\n2. Read the four sentences in the glossary specimen.\n3. Confirm the glossary names the kinds file as the home.\n4. Compare the sentences. They match, or the glossary is stale and the kinds file wins.\n\nThe practice fails in this very file if you find a second \"home\" for those sentences that does not point back at the kinds file. The practice fails in a product if a page reprints the sentences and, when they drift, someone edits the page instead of the kinds file.\n","kind":"best_practice","stratum":"proof","license":"CC-BY-4.0","shot":"na","tags":["source","fact","home","copy"],"author_name":"Campaign Hub","author_url":"https://campaignhub.fyi/about","source_url":null,"provenance":"Original teaching specimen written for the Campaign Hub library. Not a transcript of a private run.","maturity":"practiced","audience_role":"any","safety_class":"public_teaching","harness":["generic"],"use_when":"Use this practice when a fact is about to be copied into a second file. The second file names the home. It does not become a rival definition.","avoid_when":"Do not keep two editable definitions of the same fact. Do not 'fix' a drift by editing the copy and leaving the home stale. Edit the home, then point at it.","eval_checks":[{"id":"HOME-1","text":"For one fact, a stranger can point at a single home. Any second copy names that home, and on disagreement the home wins.","how_checked":"Pick the stratum sentences. Their home is the kinds file. This shelf's glossary copy names that home. If the two disagree, the kinds file wins and the copy is stale."}],"published_at":"2026-09-24T21:59:21.000Z","updated_at":"2026-09-24T21:59:21.000Z","sensor":null,"edges":[{"from":"one-value-one-source","to":"specimen","kind":"cites","title":"Specimen"}]}