Icing and fuel-out
The stop pair for this library: icing is executing an untrusted specimen or letting a sensor publish. Fuel-out is a half-applied schema with no previous release to return to.
When to use
Use this pair before running a specimen or applying a schema change. Icing stops the wrong kind of work. Fuel-out stops work that would burn the return path.
When not to
Do not treat this pair as permission to run a specimen 'carefully.' Execution of an untrusted specimen is the icing condition. Stop means stop.
Author-attested
Original teaching specimen written for the Campaign Hub library. Not a transcript of a private run.
# Icing and fuel-out
This file is a kill pair: the icing condition and the fuel-out condition for this library.
## When to use
Use this pair when the work is a public library of specimens. Before you run something, and before you migrate something, read the two stops. Icing is work of the wrong kind. Fuel-out is work that consumes the path back.
Both stops are for this class of work. They are not a general slogan about being careful.
## When not to
Do not borrow this pair as a reason to execute a specimen inside a sandbox and call the icing handled. The icing condition is executing an untrusted specimen. A sandbox is still execution.
Do not apply a schema change "just halfway" because you intend to finish later. Halfway, with no previous release you can return to, is the fuel-out.
## The specimen
The artifact is this kill pair.
```text
kill pair for: a public library of specimens that people submit, people publish, and strangers read
icing - stop, this is the wrong kind of work:
1. Executing an untrusted specimen.
A specimen is text a stranger reuses. It is not a program the library runs.
Stop includes "just this once" and "only in a sandbox."
2. Letting a sensor publish.
A sensor may advise the person who publishes.
A score, a safety probability, or a kind suggestion does not open the publish gate and does not write the kind.
Stop if a pipeline is about to set published from a score.
fuel-out - stop, continuing burns the return path:
1. A half-applied schema change with no previous release to return to.
Before a schema change, name the release you can roll back to.
If you cannot name it, do not apply the change.
A migration applied in production before the shelf's own checks are green is this condition.
not icing and not fuel-out:
- refusing a payload
- a person publishing after they have read the specimen
- a check exiting 1
a red check is a result, not a reason to run the specimen or to migrate anyway
on either stop:
- do not proceed
- do not invent a smaller version of the same act
- record which condition fired
```
This pair guards the one-specimen campaign and any larger effort built the same way. The campaign may compose beads and gates. It may not execute the specimen those beads produce, and it may not let the sensor become the principal. The schema the library stores is applied only when a previous release is named and the way back is real.
## How a stranger checks it
A stranger checks the pair by pointing, then by asking two questions of a real plan.
1. In the fenced text, icing contains both "executing an untrusted specimen" and "letting a sensor publish." Fuel-out contains a half-applied schema with no previous release. If either heading is missing, the pair is broken.
2. Each condition's action is stop. A condition that says "proceed if you are sure" fails.
3. Ask of a plan: does any step execute a specimen, or let a score set published? If yes, icing has already fired. Do not proceed.
4. Ask of a plan: does a schema change name the previous release a person can return to? If it does not, fuel-out has already fired. Do not apply the change.
A pair that lists only icing, or only fuel-out, fails. The two stops are the specimen.
How a stranger checks it
- KILL-1 Icing names executing an untrusted specimen and a sensor publishing. Fuel-out names a half-applied schema with no previous release. Each has a stop. Read the fenced pair. Confirm both icing conditions and the fuel-out condition are present, and that each condition's action is stop rather than proceed.