# A person publishes This file is a gate: a hold that opens only when a person approves. ## When to use Use this gate wherever a specimen would move from pending to published. The hold is closed by default. It opens when a person approves, and only then. A sensor may leave advice beside the specimen before the person decides. The advice is input to the person. It is not the key to the hold. ## When not to Do not open the hold because a score is high, because a score is low and someone wants to "get it off the queue," or because a kind suggestion looks confident. Do not let the intake clerk open it. The clerk's authority ends at the pending queue. Do not let the absence of a sensor reading count as an approval. A missing reading leaves the hold closed until a person acts. It does not refuse the person the right to act. ## The specimen The artifact is this gate. ```text hold: publish closed_by_default: true opens_when: - a person takes an approve action on a pending specimen - the action is theirs, not a copied score and not a default remains_closed_when: - no person has approved - the only new information is a score - the only new information is a suggestion of a different kind - the intake clerk has accepted the row sensor: may: attach advice for the person to read may_not: open this hold may_not: set the specimen to published may_not: write the kind field a kind suggestion is displayed beside the person's choice the person's choice stays the kind refuse_and_approve_are_both_human: true a refusal is a person's act and leaves the specimen unpublished an approval is a person's act and opens the hold not_evidence_of_open: - a file that says complete - a high score - an empty note - the submitter's confidence ``` The policy on attack procedures still applies at this gate. A person does not open the hold on a working payload. The sensor may warn. The warning does not replace the person's refusal, and it does not become a publish. The home of that limit is the specimen "No attack procedures." ## How a stranger checks it A stranger checks the gate by trying to open it with everything except a person. 1. Read `opens_when`. The only key is a person's approve action. 2. Read `remains_closed_when`. A score alone, a kind suggestion alone, and the clerk's accept are all still closed. 3. Read the sensor block. `may_not` includes open, publish, and write the kind. 4. If you have a running system, submit a specimen, attach a glowing score, and do not approve. The specimen is still pending. Then approve as a person. Now it is published. A copy whose `opens_when` includes "score at or above a line" fails this check. The block line, if a product has one, belongs to the sensor's question pack. It can block a person's approve when the product says so. It cannot open this hold by itself.