{"slug":"human-publishes","title":"A person publishes","description":"A publish hold that opens only when a person approves. A sensor may advise. A score does not open the hold, and it does not change the kind.","body":"# A person publishes\n\nThis file is a gate: a hold that opens only when a person approves.\n\n## When to use\n\nUse this gate wherever a specimen would move from pending to published. The hold is closed by default. It opens when a person approves, and only then.\n\nA sensor may leave advice beside the specimen before the person decides. The advice is input to the person. It is not the key to the hold.\n\n## When not to\n\nDo not open the hold because a score is high, because a score is low and someone wants to \"get it off the queue,\" or because a kind suggestion looks confident.\n\nDo not let the intake clerk open it. The clerk's authority ends at the pending queue. Do not let the absence of a sensor reading count as an approval. A missing reading leaves the hold closed until a person acts. It does not refuse the person the right to act.\n\n## The specimen\n\nThe artifact is this gate.\n\n```text\nhold: publish\nclosed_by_default: true\n\nopens_when:\n  - a person takes an approve action on a pending specimen\n  - the action is theirs, not a copied score and not a default\n\nremains_closed_when:\n  - no person has approved\n  - the only new information is a score\n  - the only new information is a suggestion of a different kind\n  - the intake clerk has accepted the row\n\nsensor:\n  may: attach advice for the person to read\n  may_not: open this hold\n  may_not: set the specimen to published\n  may_not: write the kind field\n  a kind suggestion is displayed beside the person's choice\n  the person's choice stays the kind\n\nrefuse_and_approve_are_both_human: true\na refusal is a person's act and leaves the specimen unpublished\nan approval is a person's act and opens the hold\n\nnot_evidence_of_open:\n  - a file that says complete\n  - a high score\n  - an empty note\n  - the submitter's confidence\n```\n\nThe policy on attack procedures still applies at this gate. A person does not open the hold on a working payload. The sensor may warn. The warning does not replace the person's refusal, and it does not become a publish. The home of that limit is the specimen \"No attack procedures.\"\n\n## How a stranger checks it\n\nA stranger checks the gate by trying to open it with everything except a person.\n\n1. Read `opens_when`. The only key is a person's approve action.\n2. Read `remains_closed_when`. A score alone, a kind suggestion alone, and the clerk's accept are all still closed.\n3. Read the sensor block. `may_not` includes open, publish, and write the kind.\n4. If you have a running system, submit a specimen, attach a glowing score, and do not approve. The specimen is still pending. Then approve as a person. Now it is published.\n\nA copy whose `opens_when` includes \"score at or above a line\" fails this check. The block line, if a product has one, belongs to the sensor's question pack. It can block a person's approve when the product says so. It cannot open this hold by itself.\n","kind":"gate","stratum":"structure","license":"CC-BY-4.0","shot":"na","tags":["gate","publish","person","sensor"],"author_name":"Campaign Hub","author_url":"https://campaignhub.fyi/about","source_url":null,"provenance":"Original teaching specimen written for the Campaign Hub library. Not a transcript of a private run.","maturity":"practiced","audience_role":"principal","safety_class":"public_teaching","harness":["generic"],"use_when":"Use this gate on the publish path so a specimen stays pending until a person approves it. The sensor may speak first. The person decides.","avoid_when":"Do not let a score, a kind suggestion, or an empty moderation note open this gate. Do not bypass it because the submitter is also an admin.","eval_checks":[{"id":"GATE-1","text":"The hold opens only on a person's approve, and a score or a kind suggestion cannot open it or rewrite the kind.","how_checked":"Read the fenced gate. Confirm opens_when is a person's approve, and that score, sensor, and kind suggestion are each forbidden to open the hold or write the kind."}],"published_at":"2026-09-24T21:59:21.000Z","updated_at":"2026-09-24T21:59:21.000Z","sensor":null,"edges":[{"from":"human-publishes","to":"no-attack-procedures","kind":"cites","title":"No attack procedures"},{"from":"record-dont-publish","to":"human-publishes","kind":"cites","title":"Record, do not publish"},{"from":"one-specimen-campaign","to":"human-publishes","kind":"composes","title":"A campaign that ships one specimen"},{"from":"intake-clerk","to":"human-publishes","kind":"requires","title":"Intake clerk"},{"from":"name-the-consumer","to":"human-publishes","kind":"requires","title":"Name the consumer"}]}