{"slug":"four-scores-two-nouls","title":"Four scores, two safety questions","description":"A scorecard of four advisory scores, two yes-or-no safety questions that can block a publish, and a kind suggestion that never overwrites the kind a person chose.","body":"# Four scores, two safety questions\n\nThis file is a scorecard: the dimensions a sensor may score, and the decisions those scores must not make.\n\n## When to use\n\nUse this card when you are wiring a sensor to the moderate step, or when you are reading a sensor panel and need to remember what you are allowed to do with each number.\n\nThe card is about decisions. It is not the question wording, and it is not the numeric block line. Those live in the sensor question pack. If this card and that pack disagree on a threshold, the pack wins, and this card should not grow a second copy of the number.\n\n## When not to\n\nDo not use a high reusability score as an approval. Do not use a low freshness score as a delete. Advisory scores inform the person who publishes. They do not take the person's pen.\n\nDo not let a kind suggestion write the kind field. The person chose the kind. The suggestion may sit beside that choice. It may not replace it, including when the suggestion is confident.\n\n## The specimen\n\nThe artifact is this scorecard.\n\n```text\nscorecard: four scores, two safety questions\n\nadvisory scores - inform the person, never publish, never relabel, never block by themselves:\n  reusability\n    asks: can a stranger reuse this without the author and without the author's machine?\n    decision: advise\n  checkability\n    asks: can a stranger observe a broken copy failing?\n    decision: advise\n  completeness\n    asks: can someone else pick this up as a finished thing?\n    decision: advise\n  freshness\n    asks: does the specimen locate itself in time, or say why it is not tied to a version?\n    decision: advise\n\nsafety questions - yes or no, and a yes can block a publish:\n  operational attack\n    asks: does this give a procedure, commands, parameters, or a payload for compromise, credential theft, malware, or an availability attack?\n    a named failure, or a defense without a working payload, is not a yes\n    decision: can block publish\n  private material\n    asks: does this contain a live secret, a real person's private matter, or an internal host together with an operator procedure?\n    decision: can block publish\n\nkind suggestion:\n  asks: which single kind best fits the text?\n  decision: display only\n  writes the kind field: no\n  the kind a person chose remains the kind\n\nwhat no score on this card may do:\n  - open the publish gate\n  - set status to published\n  - overwrite slug, title, or kind\n  - execute the specimen\n\nhome of the question wording and of the numeric block line: the library's sensor question pack\nthis card does not copy that number\n```\n\nThe four names match the teaching subject of this specimen: reusability, checkability, completeness, and freshness advise. The two safety questions can block. The kind suggestion never overwrites. The publish gate, whose home is \"A person publishes,\" still opens only for a person. A block stops that person until they deal with the safety hit through whatever override the product records. The block is not itself a publish, and the absence of a score is not a block. A person can still publish when the sensor has no reading, and a person still cannot publish a working payload just because the sensor was down. The limit on payloads has its own home, \"No attack procedures.\"\n\n## How a stranger checks it\n\nA stranger checks the card by reading the decision column, not the adjectives.\n\n1. The four scores each say `advise`. If any of them says `publish` or `block`, the card fails.\n2. The two safety questions are yes-or-no, and each decision says it can block a publish. If they are scored on a polite gradient with no block, the card fails.\n3. Kind suggestion says display only and `writes the kind field: no`.\n4. The card does not contain a second copy of the numeric block line. Naming the question pack as the home of that number is required. Pasting the number here fails the \"one home\" test.\n5. Nothing on the card opens the publish gate.\n\nIf a product shows a sensor panel, compare the panel's verbs to this column. Advice may be styled loudly. It still may not be the approve button.\n","kind":"scorecard","stratum":"proof","license":"CC-BY-4.0","shot":"na","tags":["scorecard","sensor","safety","kind"],"author_name":"Campaign Hub","author_url":"https://campaignhub.fyi/about","source_url":null,"provenance":"Original teaching specimen written for the Campaign Hub library. Not a transcript of a private run.","maturity":"practiced","audience_role":"principal","safety_class":"public_teaching","harness":["generic"],"use_when":"Use this scorecard when a sensor will read a specimen and a person needs to know which readings advise, which can block a publish, and which must not relabel.","avoid_when":"Do not let an advisory score open or close the publish gate by itself. Do not copy the sensor's block line onto this card. That number has one home, the question pack.","eval_checks":[{"id":"SCORE-1","text":"Reusability, checkability, completeness, and freshness are advisory. Two safety questions can block publish. Kind suggestion does not write the kind.","how_checked":"Read the decision column of the fenced card. Confirm the four scores say advise, both safety questions say block publish, and kind suggestion says display only."}],"published_at":"2026-09-24T21:59:21.000Z","updated_at":"2026-09-24T21:59:21.000Z","sensor":null,"edges":[{"from":"four-scores-two-nouls","to":"no-attack-procedures","kind":"cites","title":"No attack procedures"}]}