Defect pass

PromptpieceCC-BY-4.0practiced By Campaign Hub

A prompt that judges one piece of work against a written checklist, lists defects, and stops. It does not rewrite the work it was asked to judge.

When to use

Use this prompt when a reviewer needs defects listed against a checklist that is already written, and the work itself must stay unchanged.

When not to

Do not use this prompt when you want a rewrite, a cleanup, or a new draft. Do not use it when the checklist is still unwritten. The prompt does not invent criteria.

Author-attested

Original teaching specimen written for the Campaign Hub library. Not a transcript of a private run.

Community-submitted content. Prompts, skills, and agent instructions can contain hidden or malicious instructions (prompt injection). Review it before running it in any agent that has tool access, secrets, or the ability to spend money or send messages.
# Defect pass This file is a prompt: one instruction, one job, and a stop. ## When to use Use this prompt for a single judging pass. You already have a checklist, and you already have the work. You want each checklist item marked pass or defect, with a quote where the work misses, and then you want the judge to stop. It fits a review seat, a second pass after an author finishes, or any moment when rewriting would hide the thing you meant to measure. ## When not to Do not paste this prompt when you want the work improved in place. A defect list and a rewrite are different jobs, and this prompt refuses the second one. Do not paste it when you hope the judge will notice "anything else that seems wrong." Items that are not on the checklist are out of the pass. Write them onto the checklist first if you want them judged. ## The specimen The artifact is this prompt. Replace the two marked slots. Do not add a third task. ```text Defect pass. You will receive a checklist and a piece of work. Judge the work against the checklist. Then stop. Checklist: {{checklist}} Work: {{work}} Instructions: - Use only the checklist items written above. - For each item, write one line. - A passing line is PASS, then the item. - A failing line is DEFECT, then the item, then a short quote from the work that shows the miss. - If you notice a problem that is not on the checklist, leave it out. - Do not rewrite the work. - Do not offer a replacement sentence, a patched paragraph, or a "suggested fix." - After the last checklist item, write DONE and stop. ``` ## How a stranger checks it Run the prompt on a fixture you build in five minutes. 1. Write a checklist of three items. 2. Write a short work sample that misses exactly one of those items. Give the miss a phrase you can quote. 3. Also put one obvious flaw in the work that is not on the checklist. A spelling error is enough, if spelling is not a checklist item. 4. Read the reply. The pass is good when the missed item is a DEFECT line with that quote, the other two items are PASS, the off-checklist flaw is absent, and there is no rewritten version of the work. A reply that repairs the work fails this check even if every defect line is correct. A reply that adds the off-checklist flaw fails this check.

How a stranger checks it

Related

prompt review defects checklist

view raw view JSON